
Nick's Peanot Butter Cup Ice Cream
What You Should Know
Nick's Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream arrives in a 16 fl oz resealable pint and lives in the frozen desserts aisle, usually shelved alongside premium pints, light or reduced-sugar frozen novelties, and other 'better-for-you' frozen treats. You might spot it near other branded low-sugar or protein-enhanced ice creams rather than next to mass-market tubs. It fits shopping trips where shoppers want an indulgent dessert without conventional sugar — after a grocery run for weekend treats, for movie-night pick-ups, or as a stash for game-day hosting. The brand positions itself as an indulgent, health-aware alternative: marketing focused on low sugar, lower calories, and modern sweeteners appeals to adults trying to manage calories, carbs, or blood sugar while still craving classic flavors. Packaging tends to lean clean and premium rather than child-focused; expect minimal kid-branding, calls out low-sugar/no-sugar-added style benefits and natural flavoring, but no organic certification. In plain processing terms, this is a highly formulated frozen dessert built from dairy, isolated proteins, multiple sugar substitutes, fibre, emulsifiers, gums, and modified plant oils. Sensory notes: the base is cold, creamy, and dense from dairy protein and fat, with peanut butter cup pieces adding a firmer, slightly crystalline crunch and bitter-sweet cocoa edges; a noticeable cooling sensation from polyol sweeteners can appear. Rituals around it are casual — scooping into bowls for solo indulgence, sharing a few spoonfuls at a small gathering, or pairing with coffee for a weekend treat. The overall story: a modern, engineered comfort dessert that trades traditional sugar for processed alternatives to deliver a familiar peanut-butter-and-chocolate experience with a weight-conscious pitch.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Cream,, Dairy, Protein, Blend, (Water,, Milk, Protein, Concentrate,, Whey, Protein, Isolate,, Allulose),, Water,, Peanut, Butter, Cups(Coconut, Oil,, Peanuts,, Maltitol,, Lactitol,, Cocoa, Processed, with, Alkali,, Soy, Lecithin,, Salt,, Vanilla, Extract),, Soluble, Corn, Fiber,, Allulose,, EPG, (Modified, Plant-Based, Oil),, Peanut, Butter,, Erythritol,, Less, than, 2%, of:, Coconut, Oil,, Natural, Flavor,, Corn, Starch,, Locust, Bean, Gum,, Cocoa, Processed, with, Alkali,, Steviol, Glycosides,, Salt,, Sorbitol,, Guar, Gum,, Cellulose, Gum,, Cellulose, Gel,, Mono, &, Diglycerides,, Locust, Bean, Gum..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Coconut Oil - Seed oil high in omega-6 fatty acids
- •Soy Lecithin - Processed emulsifier
- •Mono & Diglycerides - Processed emulsifier
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
Contains multiple industrial ingredients and additives (polyol sweeteners, allulose, protein isolates, modified plant oil, emulsifiers, gums, soluble fiber) and is reformulated to mimic a traditional food, consistent with NOVA group 4 ultraprocessed foods.
Explore Similar Products
Frozen Foods at Foodtown
See every Frozen Foods option at Foodtown
Nick's products
Explore the full Nick's lineup
High Fiber Snacks
Stay full longer with fiber-rich foods
Low Sugar Snacks
Keep sugar intake in check
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Dye-Free Snacks
No artificial colors or dyes
Others also viewed

Red Baron Stacked Pepperoni 2 Pack Pizza
Red Baron

Stouffers Lasagna with Meat & Sauce
Stouffer's

Pictsweet Vegetables For The Air Fryer Parmesan Cauliflower
Pictsweet Farms

Evergreen Waffles Frozen Peanut Butter Banana
Evergreen

Alpen Potstickers, Chicken
Tai Pei

Wow Bao Chicken Teriyaki
Wow Bao

Halo Top Mix-Ins Caramel Cookie Crunch Ice Cream
Halo Top

Eggo Buttermilk Pancakes 24ct
Eggo

PF Changs Home Menu Meal for Two Beef with Broccoli
P.F. Chang's

B&J Americone, Non Dairy
Ben & Jerry's

Marie Callender's Honey Roasted Turkey Breast
Marie Callender's

Crav'n Flavor Vanilla Ice Cream Cup 12Ct
Crav'n Flavor
Common Questions about Nick's Peanot Butter Cup Ice Cream
That depends on your definition of healthy! With only 120 calories per serving and low sugar content, it can fit into a balanced diet, especially as a treat. However, it's important to note that it's not particularly high in protein or fiber compared to some other snacks, so think of it as a fun indulgence rather than a health food.
