
Sargento Shredded Cheese, Off The Block, Extra Sharp Cheddar
What You Should Know
SARGENTO Shredded Extra Sharp Cheddar sits in the refrigerated dairy aisle near other shredded and block cheeses, close to specialty butters and deli-sliced cheeses. Packaged in a small plastic bag for convenience, it catches the eye with messaging about "real, natural cheese" and bold flavor. This product is built for quick meals and familiar occasions — tossed onto morning burritos, folded into grilled cheese sandwiches, sprinkled over chili on game day, or melted into a weeknight pasta. The brand leans into a family-owned, American cheese heritage, targeting busy households and cooks who want authentic cheese flavor with modern convenience; marketing emphasizes natural ingredients and bold taste rather than gourmet exclusivity. On the label you will notice health-halo language like "real, natural cheese" and claims about being shredded from blocks; there is no organic certification and the ingredient list also includes functional additives listed in small type. In plain terms, this is pre-shredded cheese that has been processed to maintain texture and shelf stability — it includes anti-caking agents (potato starch, powdered cellulose) and a mold inhibitor (natamycin) beyond simple milk, culture, salt and enzymes. Sensory notes: bright orange color from annatto, a firm-but-tender shredded bite that melts smoothly into hot dishes, and a pronounced sharp, nutty, savory flavor. Rituals around it are practical and comforting — a quick sprinkle from the bag into recipes or onto plates, a go-to for families and cooks looking for bold cheddar flavor without slicing from a block.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Cheddar, Cheese, [Pasteurized, Milk,, Cheese, Culture,, Salt,, Enzymes,, Annatto, (Vegetable, Color)],, Potato, Starch, and, Powdered, Cellulose, (TO, PREVENT, CAKING),, NATAMYCIN, (A, NATURAL, MOLD, INHIBITOR)..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •NATAMYCIN - Synthetic preservative
- •Annatto (Vegetable Color) - Artificial coloring
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
Pre-shredded cheese contains industrial additives (potato starch, powdered cellulose, natamycin) and is processed for shelf stability and convenience, placing it in the ultra-processed category.
Others also viewed

Simply Lemonade All Natural
Simply

Lactaid Reduced Fat 2% Milk
Lactaid

The Laughing Cow Babybel Cheeses, Semisoft, Mini, Original
Mini Babybel®

Breakstone Cottage Cheese, Low Fat 2%
Breakstone's

Daisy Cottage Cheese, 4% Milfat
Daisy

Chobani Zero Sugar Greek Mixed Berry
Chobani

Organic Valley Organic Milk, Whole
Organic Valley®

Kerrygold Naturally Softer Pure Irish Butter
Kerrygold

Chobani Yogurt, Greek, Nonfat, Raspberry On The Bottom 5.3 oz
Chobani
La Yogurt Peach
La Yogurt

Oatly Oat Milk, 64Floz, Original
Oatly

Tillamook Shredded Mozzarella Cheese
Tillamook
Common Questions about Sargento Shredded Cheese, Off The Block, Extra Sharp Cheddar
Healthiness can be subjective and really depends on your personal dietary goals. Sargento's extra sharp cheddar is a good source of protein and calcium, which are essential nutrients. However, it does contain some sodium and saturated fat, so if you're watching those, you might want to enjoy it in moderation.
