
McCormick Imitation Vanilla Extract
What You Should Know
McCormick Imitation Vanilla Extract is a small, budget-minded bottle you’ll find in the baking aisle alongside pure vanilla extracts, vanilla pastes, chocolate chips, and boxed cake mixes. Packaged as a 2 fl oz bottle with a screw cap pour spout, it presents as a pantry workhorse for everyday baking rather than a specialty ingredient. Shoppers reach for it on grocery runs for cookies, cupcakes, pancakes, frosting and quick dessert fixes — occasions that range from holiday cookie swaps to weekend morning pancakes and last-minute dinner-party desserts. The brand positioning leans on McCormick’s long-standing spice reputation: dependable, mainstream, and value-oriented, pitched to home bakers and families who want a consistent vanilla flavor without the price variability of pure vanilla extract. The front label emphasizes “Premium Flavor” and “artificially flavored” while the description touts vanillin plus natural extractives for depth; there are no organic or “all-natural” certifications and no child-specific branding, though the promise of easy, crowd-pleasing baking has a family-friendly feel. In plain processing context: this is a highly processed flavoring made from synthesized vanillin and added sweeteners/coloring to standardize taste and appearance. Sensory notes: a thin, alcohol-forward liquid that smells strongly of sweet vanilla with a slightly synthetic edge; visually it’s clear to light brown from caramel color. Ritual use is simple and precise — measured by teaspoon into batter or frosting, a small dash that reliably colors the aroma of the kitchen. Its story in American grocery culture is as the affordable, consistent shortcut for everyday and holiday baking when cost and predictability trump artisanal sourcing.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Water,, Alcohol,, Natural, Flavorings, (Including, Extractives, of, Cocoa, and, Extractives, of, Tea),, Vanillin, and, Other, Artificial, Flavorings,, Corn, Syrup, &, Caramel, Color..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Caramel Color - Artificial coloring
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
Contains industrially produced additives (vanillin and other artificial flavorings), corn syrup and caramel color, and is formulated to provide a standardized flavor—characteristics of ultra-processed foods.
Explore Similar Products
Cooking & Baking at Foodtown
See every Cooking & Baking option at Foodtown
McCormick products
Explore the full McCormick lineup
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Low Sodium Snacks
Heart-healthy low-sodium choices
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Dairy-Free Snacks
No milk, cheese, or dairy ingredients
Others also viewed

McCormick Perfect Pinch Italian Seasoning
McCormick

Schar Artisan Baker Bread Multigrain
Schar

Louisiana Seasoned Crispy Breading Mix, Chicken Fry
Louisiana Fish Fry Products

Betty Crocker Delights Supermoist Cake Mix Lemon
Betty Crocker

International Collection Sesame Oil, Toasted
International Collection

Pillsbury Cake Mix, Moist Supreme Devil's Food
Pillsbury

Betty Crocker Reeses PB Bar Mix
Reese's

Spice Classics, Garlic Salt
Spice Classics®

Badia Organic Curry Powder
Badia
4C Salt Free Bread Crumbs, Seasoned
4C
Mazola Corn Oil
Mazola

Morton Iodized Salt & Black Pepper 1 ea
Morton
Common Questions about McCormick Imitation Vanilla Extract
Well, 'healthy' can mean different things to different people. This extract is low in calories and has no added sugars, which might appeal to those watching their sugar intake. However, it does contain artificial flavorings and high fructose corn syrup, so if you're looking for a clean, whole-food ingredient, you might want to explore other options.
