
Mccadam Sharp Yellow Cheddar
What You Should Know
McCadam Sharp Yellow Cheddar presents itself as a classic, regionally rooted block cheese that you’d find in the refrigerated dairy aisle or specialty cheese case, shelved alongside other cheddars, sliced deli cheeses, and shredded cheese packs. Packaged as an 8 oz vacuum-sealed wedge, the cheese’s deep golden hue (from annatto) and simple label call to mind old‑school farm cooperatives and New York dairy country. It’s marketed with heritage cues — “A Tradition of quality cheese since 1876” — and practical claims such as lactose free, gluten free, halal, and “no animal rennet,” appealing to families, multicultural households, and shoppers looking for straightforward, trustworthy products. The label leans on natural and local signals: pasteurized milk, state‑grown certification, and a cooperative brand story; there’s a modest health-halo in the “no artificial growth hormone” note. In plain processing terms, this is a traditionally made cheddar from pasteurized milk, starter cultures, salt and enzymes that has been aged to develop a sharp flavor — a moderate level of processing compared with fresh milk but not an industrial analog cheese. Sensory-wise, expect a firm yet slightly crumbly texture, a concentrated sharp savory flavor, and a creamy finish; the annatto adds a warm orange color without altering taste. Rituals include slicing for sandwiches, grating for mac and cheese, cubing for snack plates, or melting over burgers. It fits both everyday kitchen use and casual entertaining: familiar, reliable, and positioned as a no‑nonsense regional cheddar for shoppers who value provenance and simple ingredient lists.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Fresh, Pasteurized, Milk,, Cheese, Cultures,, Salt,, Enzymes,, Annatto, (for, Color)..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Annatto - Artificial coloring
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Processed Food
Why this score?
This is a processed food (NOVA 3): made from pasteurized milk with added cultures, salt, enzymes and annatto, using standard cheesemaking and aging rather than being an unprocessed whole food or an ultraprocessed formulation.
Explore Similar Products
Dairy at Foodtown
See every Dairy option at Foodtown
Mccadam products
Explore the full Mccadam lineup
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Low Sodium Snacks
Heart-healthy low-sodium choices
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Non-Ultra-Processed Snacks
Avoid the most heavily processed foods
Others also viewed

Pillsbury Pull Apart Monkey Bread
Pillsbury

Country Crock Heavy Whipping Plant Cream
Country Crock

Cracker Barrel Chunk Cheese, Sharp Cheddar
Cracker Barrel

Danimals Smoothies, 12 Pack, Strawberry Explosion And Strikin' Strawberry-Kiwi
Danimals
Florida Natural Passion Fruit Splash
Florida's Natural

Turkey Hill Green Tea With Ginseng & Honey
Turkey Hill

Oui French Style Mango Yogurt
Oui

Activia Dailies Strawberry, Banana & Mix Berry 8 Pack
Activia

Cacique Cotija, 10Oz
Cacique
Slate Milk Lactose Free Vanilla Latte
Slate

Lifeway Kefir, Cherry 32 fl oz
Lifeway

Coffee mate French Vanilla Flavored Coffee Creamer, Zero Sugar, Gluten-Free, 126 Servings
Coffee mate
Common Questions about Mccadam Sharp Yellow Cheddar
Well, 'healthy' can be a bit of a slippery term, can't it? Mccadam Sharp Yellow Cheddar is a tasty cheese option that contains simple ingredients like milk and cheese cultures, but it does have artificial color from annatto. It's not a health food per se, especially if you're looking for high protein or fiber, but it can definitely be enjoyed in moderation as part of a balanced diet.
