
Cabot Cheese, Aged Cheddar, Extra Sharp
What You Should Know
Cabot Cheese, Aged Cheddar Extra Sharp is typically found in the refrigerated cheese case of mainstream supermarkets and natural-food grocers, shelved with other specialty block cheddars, artisanal cheeses and packaged deli items — often near crackers, charcuterie, and craft beer displays. It reads as an every-day premium: a New England co‑op story that appeals to shoppers seeking full-flavored, straightforward dairy. Shoppers reach for this 8 oz block on trips for weekend entertaining, game-day spreads, or to upgrade a grilled cheese or pasta sauce. Brand positioning leans into heritage and craft: Cabot is presented as a farmer-owned cooperative with an East Coast bite, targeting adult consumers who appreciate bold flavor without gimmicks — foodies, families who entertain, and home cooks who want reliable melting and snacking cheese. The label emphasizes “natural” cues — pasteurized milk, simple ingredients, and claims like “naturally gluten-free” and “zero grams of lactose” create a health-halo without organic certification; there’s no kid-focused branding or bright cartooning. Processing context: this is an aged, fermented dairy product made from pasteurized milk, cultures, salt and enzymes — a traditional food made by controlled processing rather than an industrially reformulated product. Sensory details highlight a creamy, dense texture with a slight crumble, a citrusy, tangy top note and a full-bodied savory finish; it comes as an 8 oz sealed block (foil/plastic-wrapped with a branded label) and is used in rituals from slicing for a beer board to melting on sandwiches or stirring into sauces. Overall it feels familiar, robust and reliably snackable.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Fresh, Pasteurized, Milk,, Cheese, Cultures,, Salt,, Enzymes..
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Processed Food
Why this score?
Made from pasteurized milk, cheese cultures, salt and enzymes and aged using traditional methods, this is a processed but minimally-ingredient natural cheese rather than an ultraprocessed reformulated product.
Explore Similar Products
Dairy at Foodtown
See every Dairy option at Foodtown
Cabot Creamery products
Explore the full Cabot Creamery lineup
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Dye-Free Snacks
No artificial colors or dyes
Non-Ultra-Processed Snacks
Avoid the most heavily processed foods
Others also viewed

Oscar Mayer Bacon, Lower Sodium, Naturally Hardwood Smoked
Oscar Mayer

Simply Lemonade
Simply

Fage Yogurt, Greek, Strained 5.3 oz
Fage

Dannon Fruit on the Bottom Peach Low Fat Yogurt, Gluten Free Snacks with Real Peach Pieces, Good Source of Calcium and Vitamin D, 5.3 OZ Yogurt Container
Dannon

Cabot Cheese, Monterey Jack Bar
Cabot Creamery

Organic Valley Organic Milk, Reduced Fat
Organic Valley®

Oui Fench Style Yogurt, Chocolate Raspberry
Oui

Stonyfield Organic Whole Milk Pear, Spinach, Mango Pouch, 4 Pack
Stonyfield Organic

Turkey Hill Sweet Tea, Southern Brewed Style 0.5 gal
Turkey Hill

Oui Blended Pina Colada Yogurt 5 oz
Oui

Mini Babybel Light Snack Cheese, 12 Count
Mini Babybel®

Chobani Yogurt, Greek, Less Sugar, Reduced Fat, Harvest Raspberry 5.3 oz
Chobani
Common Questions about Cabot Cheese, Aged Cheddar, Extra Sharp
The Aged Cheddar is a tasty source of protein and calcium, making it a good addition to a balanced diet. However, like all cheeses, it’s best enjoyed in moderation, especially if you’re watching your saturated fat intake. So, if you're pairing it with veggies or whole-grain crackers, you're on the right track!
