
Pillsbury Frosting, Creamy Supreme Buttercream
What You Should Know
Pillsbury Creamy Supreme Buttercream Frosting is a familiar tub you’ll find in the baking aisle of mainstream grocery stores, shelved alongside cake mixes, sprinkles, canned frostings and other ready-to-use dessert toppings. It reads as a convenience product for celebratory cooking — birthdays, last-minute cupcakes, school bake sales and holiday desserts — when shoppers want a fast, consistent finish without making buttercream from scratch. Pillsbury positions this product as a family-friendly, broadly appealing brand: mass-market, nostalgia-tinged, and marketed to home bakers who value ease and reliable flavor. Packaging emphasizes convenience (a resealable 16 oz plastic tub) and flavor notes like “buttercream,” while the front messaging and colorful label elements appeal to parents and party planners rather than health-focused buyers. The label carries some health-adjacent cues—gluten-free mention in copy—but no organic certification, and it includes both “natural and artificial flavor” plus visible artificial color ingredients, which can create a misleading “treat” halo for casual shoppers. In plain terms, this is a highly processed, shelf-stable frosting made from refined sugars, vegetable fats and multiple emulsifiers, stabilizers and preservatives. Sensory experience: very sweet, thick and spreadable with a smooth, pipeable texture and a pronounced buttery-sweet flavor; colors may be brighter due to added dyes. Typical use is scoop-and-spread or transfer to a piping bag for decorating; the plastic tub and wide mouth make it a quick one-step ritual for busy home bakers. After opening it is commonly refrigerated and used up within a couple of weeks.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Sugar,, Palm, Oil,, Water,, Corn, Syrup,, Canola, Oil,, Contains, 2%, or, Less:, Salt,, Mono, and, Diglycerides,, Artificial, Color, (Including, Yellow, 5,, Red, 40,, Yellow, 6),, Polysorbate, 60,, Modified, Corn, Starch,, Potassium, Sorbate, (Preservative),, Soy, Lecithin,, Xanthan, Gum,, Citric, Acid,, Natural, and, Artificial, Flavor,, Antixidants, (Ascorbyl, Palmitate,, Mixed, Tocopherols,, Chamomile, and, Rosemary, Extracts)..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Canola Oil - Seed oil high in omega-6 fatty acids
- •Palm Oil - Seed oil high in omega-6 fatty acids
- •Mono and Diglycerides - Processed emulsifier
- •Soy Lecithin - Processed emulsifier
- •Polysorbate 60 - Processed emulsifier
- •Potassium Sorbate - Synthetic preservative
- •Yellow 5 - Artificial coloring
- •Red 40 - Artificial coloring
- •Yellow 6 - Artificial coloring
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
Contains industrial ingredients (palm/canola oil, corn syrup), multiple emulsifiers, stabilizers, artificial colors and preservatives, consistent with ultra-processed foods in NOVA group 4.
Explore Similar Products
Cooking & Baking at Foodtown
See every Cooking & Baking option at Foodtown
Pillsbury products
Explore the full Pillsbury lineup
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Low Sodium Snacks
Heart-healthy low-sodium choices
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Dairy-Free Snacks
No milk, cheese, or dairy ingredients
Others also viewed

Spice Classics, Basil Leaves
Spice Classics®

McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice
McCormick®

Pillsbury Cake Mix, Moist Supreme Strawberry
Pillsbury

Badia Spices Lemon Pepper Seasonings
Badia

Morton Sea Salt Grinder
Morton

McCormick Pure Anise Extract
McCormick®

Bisquick Pancake & Baking Mix, Original
Bisquick

Simply Organic Garlic Salt, Organic
Simply Organic

Schar Hamburger Buns
Schar

Miss Jones Baking Co. Monster Cookie Mix
Miss Jones Baking Co.

Bob's Red Mill Baking Soda
Bob's Red Mill

Simply Organic Curry Powder, Organic
Simply Organic
Common Questions about Pillsbury Frosting, Creamy Supreme Buttercream
Ah, the million-dollar question! While the Buttercream frosting isn't exactly a health food, it's all about context. If you’re looking for a sweet treat to top off a birthday cake, it fits the bill perfectly. Just remember, moderation is key—it's more of a fun indulgence than a daily staple!
