
Simple Mills Cookies Sandwich Peanut Butter
What You Should Know
Simple Mills Cookies Sandwich Peanut Butter is a compact, shelf-ready snack that you'd spot in the natural and specialty snack aisle of a typical American grocery store — often shelved near gluten-free crackers, nut-based bars, and other better-for-you cookie alternatives rather than with mainstream boxed cookies. It reads like a pantry-friendly indulgence for shoppers seeking a cleaner label on the go: a peanut-butter–filled sandwich made from cashew and peanut flours, coconut sugar, and simple stabilizers. Occasions for purchase include lunchbox upgrades, afternoon coffee breaks, road-trip snack stashes, or a quick, portioned treat during a workday. The brand projects a wellness-forward, millennial-friendly aesthetic — artisanal, ingredient-conscious, and premium-priced — targeting parents, health-minded adults, and shoppers who want indulgence with perceived nutrition. Packaging and labeling lean into health halos: “organic” qualifiers, short ingredient lists, and claims like “made with nut flours” and “sustainably sourced” palm shortening; graphics are minimalist, with muted colors rather than child-centric cartoons, so it reads as adult-oriented rather than overtly kid-branded. In plain terms it’s a commercially made, processed bakery item: ingredients are mostly recognizable whole-food derivatives but assembled in a factory. Sensory details: the cookies are slightly crumbly and tender from nut flours, with a creamy peanut-butter center and a gentle snap; sweetness is moderate from coconut sugar. Expect a small box or pouch you can tuck into a bag, a quick ritual of opening and pairing with coffee or milk, and an experience that feels both indulgent and comparatively wholesome within the packaged-snack universe.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Cashew, &, Peanut, Blend, (Cashew, Flour,, Peanut, Butter,, Peanut, Flour), Organic, Coconut, Sugar, Tapioca, Starch, Organic, Palm, Shortening, (Sustainably, Sourced), Organic, Buckwheat, Flour, Carrot, Fiber, Arrowroot, Organic, Apple, Cider, Vinegar, Sea, Salt, Baking, Soda, Peanut, Oil, Rosemary, Extract, (for, Freshness), Vanilla, Extract..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •peanut oil - Seed oil high in omega-6 fatty acids
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Processed Food
Why this score?
Ingredients are primarily whole-food-derived (nut flours, peanut butter, coconut sugar) but include processed fats and starches and are produced as a packaged snack, placing it in NOVA group 3 (processed) rather than minimally processed or clearly ultra-processed.
Explore Similar Products
Cooking & Baking at Foodtown
See every Cooking & Baking option at Foodtown
Simple Mills products
Explore the full Simple Mills lineup
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Low Sodium Snacks
Heart-healthy low-sodium choices
Dairy-Free Snacks
No milk, cheese, or dairy ingredients
Organic Certified Products
USDA organic certified options
Dye-Free Snacks
No artificial colors or dyes
Non-Ultra-Processed Snacks
Avoid the most heavily processed foods
Others also viewed

Bob's Red Mill Red Bulgur
Bob's Red Mill

McCormick Imitation Vanilla Extract Premium
McCormick®

Crisco Vegetable Oil
Crisco

Morton and Bassett Chili Powder, Chili
Morton & Bassett

McCormick Grill Mates Brazilian Steakhouse
McCormick

4C Gluten Free Bread Crumbs, Plain
4C

Earth Balance Oil Omega Blend
Smart Balance

Bob's Red Mill Cornstarch
Bob's Red Mill

Morton & Bassett Cinnamon, 100% Organic, Ground 2.2 oz
Morton & Bassett

King Arthur Multi Purpose Flour
King Arthur Baking Company

McCormick Gourmet Organic Hot Madras Curry Powder
McCormick Gourmet

Diamond Walnuts, Shelled 14 oz
Diamond
Common Questions about Simple Mills Cookies Sandwich Peanut Butter
The Peanut Butter Cookies Sandwich can fit into a balanced diet, especially if you're looking for a treat that’s made with organic ingredients. It's not exactly a health food, but at 120 calories per serving, it can satisfy your sweet tooth without overindulging. Just remember, 'healthy' is all about context — it’s a more wholesome option than many conventional cookies!
