Old Croc Extra Sharp Cheddar
What You Should Know
Old Croc Extra Sharp Cheddar is a compact, 7 oz imported wedge you’d spot in the refrigerated specialty cheese case or deli island, shelved next to other aged cheddars, imported blocks and charcuterie accoutrements. It reads like an artisanal, snackable option for shoppers assembling a cheese board or reaching for a bold grater cheese for weeknight pasta. Occasions include casual entertaining, weekend brunch spreads and snack-centric game-day prep. Brand positioning leans into a rugged, vintage persona — Australian provenance, “vintage 18+ months,” grass-fed milk and “all natural” copy craft an image of traditional, farmhouse-style cheese aimed at adult foodies who value flavor intensity and provenance; marketing skews to discerning households rather than children. Label characteristics create health halos: “grass-fed,” “Non GMO ingredients,” and “No hormones added” give a natural, wholesome cue despite no organic certification; packaging avoids cartooning or kid branding and instead favors straightforward, mature design. Processing context (in plain language): this is a cultured, aged cheese made from pasteurized milk, salt, cultures and vegetable rennet — a fermented dairy product with minimal industrial additives. Sensory details emphasize a delightfully bold bite: a dry, slightly crumbly texture that yields sharp, tangy flavor and a lingering savory finish; it’s sold wrapped in a foil or plastic-sealed wedge with a paper label and frequently appears in rituals like slicing for a cheese plate, grating over dishes, or nibbling with crackers and a glass of red. Nutritionally it’s calorie-dense and moderately high in sodium, consistent with aged hard cheeses.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Pasteurized, Milk,, Salt,, Cultures,, Enzymes, (Vegetable, Rennet)..
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Processed Food
Why this score?
This is a processed food (NOVA 3): a fermented, aged cheese made from pasteurized milk, salt, cultures and rennet with no industrial additives. It undergoes processing and aging but lacks the formulations and additives characteristic of ultra-processed foods.
Explore Similar Products
Deli at Foodtown
See every Deli option at Foodtown
Old Croc products
Explore the full Old Croc lineup
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Dye-Free Snacks
No artificial colors or dyes
Non-Ultra-Processed Snacks
Avoid the most heavily processed foods
Others also viewed

Van Holten'S Hearty Dill Pickle In A Pouch
Van Holten's
Sabra Hummus, Carmelized Onion
Sabra

Boar's Head Golden Classic Low Sodium Chicken Breast
Unknown

Belgioioso Snacking Cheese, Fresh Mozzarella
BelGioioso

BH Reggiano Parmesan
Boar's Head

Boar's Head Cheese, Pepper Jack Slices
Unknown

Boar's Head Picante Provolone, Sliced
Unknown

Belgioioso Mascarpone
BelGioioso

Supreme Mini Brie Bites In Bag
Supreme
Eiffel Tower Baby Brie
Eiffel Tower

Citterio Fresco Mortadella
Citterio

Boar's Head Bacon
Boar's Head
Common Questions about Old Croc Extra Sharp Cheddar
Well, that depends on what you mean by healthy! This cheese packs a solid protein punch with 7 grams per ounce, which is great for those looking to add a bit of muscle to their meals. However, it does contain some saturated fat and sodium, so if you’re watching those metrics, it’s best enjoyed in moderation.
