
McCormick Imitation Vanilla Extract Premium
What You Should Know
McCormick Imitation Vanilla Extract Premium (4 foz) is the pantry shorthand for everyday baking and quick flavor boosts. You’ll find it on the spice and baking aisle near other extracts, imitation and pure vanilla, baking chocolate, and shelf-stable flavorings. Shoppers reach for it during holiday-baking runs, weekly cookie-prep, and casual weekend baking when a reliable vanilla note is needed without the cost of pure extract. Positioned as an accessible, budget-friendly option from a long-established brand, the product appeals to home bakers, busy parents, and value-minded cooks who recognize the McCormick name; the marketing leans practical and familiar rather than artisanal. The label often highlights "Premium" vanilla flavor while listing familiar words like "natural flavorings," but it lacks organic certification and does not make clean-label health claims — it reads like a conventional grocery staple rather than a health-forward product. In plain terms, this is a manufactured flavoring: a blended liquid containing alcohol, flavor extracts, vanillin and artificial flavorings, corn syrup, and color — processed ingredients combined to mimic vanilla. Sensory notes: a viscous, amber-brown liquid in a small screw-top bottle with a measuring pour or drop ritual; the aroma is sweet and vanillin-forward, more candy-like than the complex floral of pure vanilla. Typical use is a teaspoon or two stirred into cake batter, cookie dough, frostings, glazes, or pan sauces for a quick flavor lift. Its convenience and consistency make it a go-to when bakers want predictable vanilla flavor without special sourcing or expense.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Water,, Alcohol,, Natural, Flavorings, (including, Extractives, of, Cocoa, and, Extractives, of, Tea),, Vanillin, and, other,, Artificial, Flavorings,, Corn, Syrup,, and, Caramel, Color..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Caramel Color - Artificial coloring
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
Contains industrially formulated additives (vanillin, artificial flavorings), corn syrup, caramel color and other processed extracts, indicating ultra-processing. This product is a manufactured flavoring blend rather than a minimally processed food.
Explore Similar Products
Others also viewed

Crisco Vegetable Oil
Crisco

Morton and Bassett Chili Powder, Chili
Morton & Bassett

McCormick Grill Mates Brazilian Steakhouse
McCormick

4C Gluten Free Bread Crumbs, Plain
4C

Earth Balance Oil Omega Blend
Smart Balance

Bob's Red Mill Cornstarch
Bob's Red Mill

Morton & Bassett Cinnamon, 100% Organic, Ground 2.2 oz
Morton & Bassett

King Arthur Multi Purpose Flour
King Arthur Baking Company

McCormick Gourmet Organic Hot Madras Curry Powder
McCormick Gourmet

Diamond Walnuts, Shelled 14 oz
Diamond

Kinders Seasoning Butchers Blend
Kinder's

Diamond of California Almonds, Slivered
Diamond of California
Common Questions about McCormick Imitation Vanilla Extract Premium
Healthiness can be a bit subjective! McCormick's imitation vanilla extract is not necessarily 'healthy' in the conventional sense, as it contains ingredients like high fructose corn syrup and artificial flavorings. However, if you’re using it in moderation for baking or flavoring, it can add a delightful vanilla essence without breaking the calorie bank.
