I Cant Believe It'S Not Butter Tub, 45 Oz
What You Should Know
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! Tub (45 oz) is a large, resealable plastic tub of spread you’ll find in the refrigerated dairy aisle, shelved near butter, margarine, and other plant-based spreads. It sits next to bread, bagels, and baking ingredients in shoppers’ mental maps—an every‑day convenience product for family kitchens. The brand trades on a familiar, cheeky promise of buttery flavor without dairy butter, positioning itself for consumers who want the taste of butter with perceived modern benefits: lower saturated fat, vegetable oil blends, and fortified vitamins. Label copy highlights "Good Oils" and "natural flavors," creating a light health halo even as the package design is bold, family-friendly and non‑organic; there are no organic certifications and the product uses mainstream, approachable branding rather than niche wellness cues. In the fridge it presents as smooth, pale yellow spread with a soft, spreadable texture straight from the tub; it melts easily on hot toast, pancakes, or vegetables and doubles as a baking shortcut in holiday cookies or savory dishes. The ritual is practical and habitual—spoon, spread, reseal. From a processing perspective, this is an industrially formulated spread made from refined vegetable oils, emulsifiers and added vitamins rather than a single-ingredient dairy product. Sensory cues are creamy and slightly sweetened by added flavorings; packaging emphasizes convenience (large size for families or entertaining). Culturally, it occupies an American middle ground between traditional butter and modern plant-based alternatives, marketed toward busy households seeking familiar taste with perceived modern nutrition tweaks.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Water,, Good, Oils, (Soybean,, Palm, Kernel,, Palm),, Salt,, Lecithin, (Soy),, Natural, Flavors,, Lactic, Acid,, Vitamins, (E,, D2,, A,, B12)(a),, Beta, Carotene, (Color., (a), Vitamins, E, Acetate, and, A, Palmitate..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Soybean - Seed oil high in omega-6 fatty acids
- •Lecithin (Soy) - Processed emulsifier
- •Beta Carotene - Artificial coloring
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
This spread is an industrially formulated product made from refined vegetable oils, emulsifiers (lecithin), flavorings and added vitamins—characteristics of ultra-processed foods (NOVA 4). The ingredient list and fortification indicate substantial industrial processing and formulation rather than minimal or culinary processing.
Explore Similar Products
Dairy at Foodtown
See every Dairy option at Foodtown
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! products
Explore the full I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! lineup
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Low Sodium Snacks
Heart-healthy low-sodium choices
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Dairy-Free Snacks
No milk, cheese, or dairy ingredients
Others also viewed

Activia Proactive Mixed Berry Prebiotic and Probiotic Yogurt, Creamy Low Fat Yogurt Cups, 5.3 oz, 4 Count
Activia

Pillsbury Caramel Rolls with Caramel Icing 8 count
Pillsbury

Kraft Deli Deluxe Cheese Slices American White
Kraft

Nathan'S N/C Coney Island Franks
Nathan's Famous

Full Circle Market Almond Milk, Original
Full Circle Market
La Yogurt Probiotic Plain Lowfat Yogurt
La Yogurt

Turkey Hill Lemonade Tea
Turkey Hill

Coffee Mate Zero Sugar Coconut Crme Coffee Creamer
Coffee mate

President Whipped Creme Original Topping
President

Uncle Matt's No Sugar Organic Strawberry Lemonade
Uncle Matt's Organic

International Delight Coffee Creamer, Peppermint Mocha
International Delight

Odyssey Cheese, Chunk in Brine, Feta, Traditional
Odyssey
Common Questions about I Cant Believe It'S Not Butter Tub, 45 Oz
Well, healthiness is a bit subjective! It has 60 calories and 6 grams of fat per tablespoon, which can fit into various diets, especially if you’re looking for a butter substitute. But remember, it’s not exactly a health food — it's more about finding balance in your overall diet.
