
I Cant Believe It's Not Butter Bowl, 15 Oz
What You Should Know
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! Bowl (15 oz) is a soft, spreadable tub of buttery-flavored spread you’ll find in the refrigerated butter and spreads aisle, sitting on the same shelf as stick butter, tubs of margarine, and plant-based spreads. Packaged in a squat plastic tub with a peel-off seal and snap-on lid, it reads like a household staple — meant to be scooped and smeared on toast, bagels, or used for quick sautéing and baking. The brand positions itself as a family-friendly, mainstream alternative to butter: familiar, affordable, and marketed toward shoppers seeking buttery flavor with claims that imply health-conscious trade-offs (lower saturated fat or “better oils”) rather than an organic or whole-food identity. Labels often emphasize “buttery taste” and sometimes tout added vitamins or “natural flavors,” creating a mild health halo despite being a manufactured product; it is not marketed as organic and carries no organic certification. Sensory details include a smooth, creamy texture that spreads easily straight from the fridge, a pale yellow color from added beta carotene, and a faint, rounded buttery aroma from flavorings. Rituals around this product are everyday — breakfast toast, sandwich spreads, melting on corn, or dolloping into a skillet for quick cooking. In plain terms it’s a highly processed spread made from blended, refined vegetable oils, emulsifiers, flavorings, and added vitamins, formulated for consistent texture and shelf stability rather than minimal processing. It sits comfortably in American grocery culture as a convenient, familiar butter stand-in for households that prioritize taste, convenience, and cost.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Water,, Good, Oils, (Soybean,, Palm, Kernel,, Palm),, Salt,, Lecithin, (Soy),, Natural, Flavors,, Lactic, Acid,, Vitamins, (E,, D2,, A,, B12), (a),, Beta, Carotene, (Color)., (a), Vitamins, E, Acetate, and, A, Palmitate..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Soybean - Seed oil high in omega-6 fatty acids
- •Lecithin - Processed emulsifier
- •Beta Carotene - Artificial coloring
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
Composed of refined vegetable oils, emulsifiers, natural flavors, and added vitamins, this product is an industrial formulation typical of ultra-processed foods. Its ingredients and manufacturing intent (to imitate butter with long shelf life and consistent texture) align with NOVA group 4.
Explore Similar Products
Dairy at Foodtown
See every Dairy option at Foodtown
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! products
Explore the full I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! lineup
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Low Sodium Snacks
Heart-healthy low-sodium choices
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Dairy-Free Snacks
No milk, cheese, or dairy ingredients
Others also viewed

Dannon Oikos Pro Strawberry 4 Pack
Oikos

Breakstones Unsalted Whipped Butter
Breakstone's

Yoplait Whips! Chocolate Mousse Style Chocolate Lowfat Yogurt Mousse
Yoplait

Danimals Squeezeables Pouches, 4 Packstrawberry Banana
Danimals

Cabot Unsalted Butter Quarters
Cabot Creamery

Pillsbury Chocolate Chunk & Chip Cookie Dough 16 oz
Pillsbury

Coffee-Mate Creamer, Sugar Free French Vanilla
Coffee mate

Organic Valley String Cheese
Organic Valley®

Smart Balance Original Tub
Smart Balance

Silk Vanilla Yogurt, 5.3 Oz
Silk

Cabot Cheese, Premium Naturally Aged Cheddar, Smooth Sharp
Cabot Creamery

Stonyfield Farm Organic Yokids Squeeze! Yogurt, Lowfat, Strawberry, 3.5 Oz
Stonyfield Organic
Common Questions about I Cant Believe It's Not Butter Bowl, 15 Oz
The term 'healthy' can be pretty subjective, right? This spread is lower in sugar and has no artificial sweeteners, which is a plus. However, it does contain some seed oils and added colors, so if you’re looking for a completely unprocessed option, you might want to explore other spreads. It’s all about balance!
