
Cabot Extra Sharp Spread
What You Should Know
Cabot Extra Sharp Spread is a refrigerated spreadable cheddar that you’ll find in the dairy aisle, usually on a shelf with other cream cheeses, cheese spreads, tubs of flavored cheeses, and near specialty butters and packaged deli cheeses. Packaged in an 8-ounce resealable tub, it presents the familiar Vermont cheddar branding — pastoral imagery and cooperative heritage — while promising a convenient, spreadable take on a farmhouse-style sharp cheddar. This product suits last-minute snack runs, laid-back weekend brunches, game-day grazing boards, or picnic and movie-night supplies when you want bold flavor without slicing a block of cheese. The brand positions itself as Vermont-born and farmer-forward, appealing to consumers who value craft cheese authenticity but also welcome modern convenience — think suburban families, millennial snackers, and beer-and-cheese hobbyists. The label leans on “Vermont Cheddar” and simple dairy ingredient names to evoke a natural, small-farm halo; it does not advertise organic certification or child-focused marketing. In plain terms, the spread is a processed cheese product: real cheddar is combined with water, whey fractions, butter, a preservative and a stabilizer so the texture stays soft and scoopable in the tub. Sensory notes: a dense, silky spread with a pronounced sharp cheddar bite, bright citrus tang on the finish, and a creamy mouthfeel that smooths over crackers or sandwiches. Rituals around use are tactile and social — smearing on crackers at a party, dolloping on an open-faced sandwich, or packing a small container for a road-trip snack. Handy, savory, and unabashedly snack-forward.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
VERMONT, CHEDDAR, CHEESE, (PASTEURIZED, MILK,, CHEESE, CULTURES,, SALT,, ENZYMES),, WATER,, REDUCED, LACTOSE, WHEY,, BUTTER, (CREAM,, SALT),, WHEY,, SORBIC, ACID, (PRESERVATIVE),, SALT,, LACTIC, ACID,, GUAR, GUM..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •sorbic acid - Synthetic preservative
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
Contains recombined dairy components, added preservatives (sorbic acid) and a stabilizer (guar gum), and is formulated to be a long-shelf, spreadable product — consistent with ultraprocessed foods (NOVA 4).
Explore Similar Products
Deli at Foodtown
See every Deli option at Foodtown
Cabot Creamery products
Explore the full Cabot Creamery lineup
Low Sugar Snacks
Keep sugar intake in check
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Dye-Free Snacks
No artificial colors or dyes
Others also viewed

Snack Factory Pretzel Crisps, Party Size, Garlic Parmesan
Snack Factory®

Boar's Head Sweet Vidalia Onions in Sauce
Boars Head

Snack Factory Pretzel Crisp Honey Mustard & Onion
Snack Factory®

Rana Italian Sausage Ravioli Family Size
Rana

Main St Bistro Double Cheese Twice Baked Potatoes 20 oz
Main St Bistro

Fratelli Beretta Roll N Go Prosciutto And Mozzarella
Fratelli Beretta

De Palo Foods Calzone, Pepperoni & Cheese
DePalo Foods

Colombus Sliced Variety Pack
COLUMBUS

Snack Factory® Pretzel Crisps Brioche Pretzel Crackers, 7.2 Oz Bag
Snack Factory®

Rana Lasagna Five Cheese Single Serve
Rana

Boars Head Pre Sliced Mozzarella Cheese
Boar's Head

Cabot Habanero Deli Cheddar Bar
Cabot Creamery
Common Questions about Cabot Extra Sharp Spread
Well, 'healthy' can mean different things depending on your goals. This spread is a tasty way to add flavor and some protein to your meals, but it's not particularly high in nutrients like fiber or vitamins. If you're looking for something to complement your diet in moderation, it can fit in just fine!
