
Bookbinder's Tartar Sauce, Traditional
What You Should Know
Bookbinder's Tartar Sauce, Traditional (9.5 oz) sits on the grocery condiment shelf among mayonnaises, sandwich spreads and seafood sauces — often near cocktail sauce, ketchup and pickled condiments or close to the seafood aisle. Marketed as a "restaurant style" and "the old original," the label leans into a classic, nostalgia-forward identity that evokes fish-and-chips counters and family seafood dinners. You might reach for this jar on weekend grocery trips for a planned fish fry, when packing sandwiches for a road trip, or during game-day and casual entertaining when a quick, familiar dip is needed. The brand positioning reads traditional and heritage-driven, aimed at shoppers seeking an old-fashioned, reliable sauce rather than an upscale artisan dressing; its messaging appeals to adults who remember diner-style condiments and to cooks wanting a ready-made finishing touch. Label cues include claims like "restaurant style" and a founding date to imply history, but no organic certification or overt "natural" badge; the ingredient list reveals added preservatives and "natural and artificial flavoring," so any health-halo is mostly nostalgic rather than health-based. In plain terms the product is highly processed: it is an industrially formulated condiment built from refined oils, sweeteners and stabilizers. Sensory details: thick, creamy and spreadable with small pickle chunks and a bright, vinegary tang, a hint of horseradish heat and a slightly sweet finish; the texture is smooth with occasional crunch from chopped pickles. Typical use is spooning or spreading from the 9.5 oz jar onto fried fish, sandwiches, crab cakes or as a dipping sauce at casual family meals.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Water,, Soybean, Oil,, Distilled, Vinegar,, Chopped, Pickles,, High, Fructose, Corn, Syrup,, Corn, Starch,, Horseradish,, Egg, Yolks,, Salt,, Sugar,, Dehydrated, Onion, and, Garlic,, Mustard, Flour,, Lemon, Juice, Concentrate,, Xanthan, Gum,, Natural, and, Artificial, Flavoring,, Sodium, Benzoate, and, Potassium, Sorbate, (Added, as, Preservatives),, EDTA-Calcium, Disodium, (to, Protect, Quality)..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Soybean Oil - Seed oil high in omega-6 fatty acids
- •Natural and Artificial Flavoring - Processed emulsifier
- •Sodium Benzoate - Synthetic preservative
- •Potassium Sorbate - Synthetic preservative
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
Contains industrial ingredients and additives (high fructose corn syrup, soybean oil, xanthan gum, preservatives, EDTA, natural and artificial flavors) and is formulated rather than minimally processed, fitting the ultraprocessed NOVA 4 category.
Explore Similar Products
Snacks, Chips & Dips at Foodtown
See every Snacks, Chips & Dips option at Foodtown
Bookbinder's products
Explore the full Bookbinder's lineup
Low Sugar Snacks
Keep sugar intake in check
Low Calorie Snacks
Light options under 150 calories
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Dairy-Free Snacks
No milk, cheese, or dairy ingredients
Dye-Free Snacks
No artificial colors or dyes
Late Night Cravings
Better choices for nighttime snacking
Movie Night Snacks
Make movie night healthier
Office Desk Snacks
Convenient snacks for work
Healthy Chips
Better chip alternatives
Others also viewed

Oreo Family Size Gold Double Stuff
Oreo

Stacy'S Bagel Chips Everything
Stacy's

Kellogg's Townhouse Dipping Thins Sea Salt
Town House

Skittles Original Stand Up Pouch
Skittles

Warhead Ooze Chewz Ropes
Warheads

Popcorners Jalapeno Poppers XL
PopCorners

Sunbelt Bakery Chewy Chocolate Chip Granola Bar 1.7 oz
Sunbelt Bakery

Dare Veggie Crisp Chipotle Cheddar
Breton

Crunch 'n Munch, Butter Toffee Popcorn
Crunch 'n Munch

Wise Potato Chips, Bbq 7.5 oz
Wise

RITZ Fresh Stacks Whole Wheat Crackers, Travel Snacks, 11.6 oz (8 Multi Snack Packs)
Ritz

Nabisco Chips Ahoy! Fresh Stacks
Chips Ahoy!
Common Questions about Bookbinder's Tartar Sauce, Traditional
Well, healthy can be a bit of a moving target! If you're looking for a condiment to jazz up your seafood or fries without packing on tons of calories, this tartar sauce is a decent choice with only 80 calories per two tablespoons. Just keep in mind that it does contain high fructose corn syrup and preservatives, so it's definitely more of an occasional treat than a staple for a health-focused diet.
