
Black Creek Cheddar 3Yryellow
What You Should Know
Black Creek Cheddar 3Yryellow is a compact 7-oz wedge of ultra-sharp, three-year aged cheddar that reads like a little chapter of Midwestern cheesemaking. You’ll find it in the refrigerated dairy aisle — often in the specialty cheese case near other aged cheddars, artisanal blocks, cured meats, crackers and charcuterie accoutrements — rather than the mass cheddar stacks. It’s marketed as a premium, craft-style cheddar: copy that highlights ‘master cheesemakers,’ long aging and milk from cows not treated with rBST creates a small-farm halo without organic certification. The label leans into tradition and flavor rather than playful kid-oriented graphics; expect a classic paper label or band on a vacuum-sealed wedge or foil-wrapped piece with visible crumbles. Sensory-first shoppers will notice a dry, crumbly texture, crystalline crunch from long aging, and a bold, layered sharpness with nutty and slightly piquant notes; it’s ideal for shaving onto a board, grating into pasta, or letting small wedges shine alongside fruit and pickles. Rituals around it skew social and culinary — pulled out for cheese boards at dinner parties, grated into a winter mac and cheese, or sliced for sandwich upgrades. Label claims include an rBST-related statement and craft/aged messaging but not organic or low-fat claims; no kid-targeted branding. In plain terms, this is a traditionally made, pasteurized and aged natural cheese — it’s processed to preserve and concentrate flavor (pasteurization, cultures and enzymes), but it is not an industrially formulated ultra-processed product.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Cultured, Pasteurized, Milk,, Salt,, Enzymes,, Annatto, (Color)..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Annatto - Artificial coloring
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Processed Food
Why this score?
Made from pasteurized cultured milk, salt, enzymes and annatto with traditional aging, this is a processed (not ultra-processed) natural cheese. Minimal ingredients and artisanal-style aging align with NOVA group 3 rather than group 4.
Explore Similar Products
Others also viewed

Columbus Charcuterie Tasting Board
COLUMBUS

HERDEZ Street Corn Medium Cup 8oz
HERDEZ

Alouette Soft Spreadable Cheese, Spinach & Artichoke
Alouette

Blount Beef Stroganoff
Blount's Family Kitchen

Boar's Head Bacon, Pre Cooked
Boar's Head

Rana Italian Sausage Ravioli
Rana

Snack Factory Pretzel Crisps, Deli Style, Buffalo Wing
Snack Factory®

Boar's Head Muenster Cheese, Natural
Boar's Head

Boar's Head Sandwich Pepperoni, pre-sliced
Boar's Head

Alouette Baby Brie
Alouette

Yucatan Organic Mild Guacamole 8 oz
Yucatan

Golds Pure Food Horseradish
Gold's
Common Questions about Black Creek Cheddar 3Yryellow
Well, that depends on what you're comparing it to! Black Creek Cheddar 3Yr packs a punch with 7 grams of protein per ounce and is low in sugar, making it a decent option for snacking or adding to meals. Just remember, 'healthy' can mean different things to different people — it’s all about balance!
