
Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream, Everything But The
What You Should Know
Ben & Jerry's "Everything But The" 16 foz pint reads like a premium freezer staple: you’ll find it in the supermarket frozen aisle, shelved beside other premium pints and novelty ice creams, often near non-dairy and artisan frozen desserts. It’s the kind of product shoppers grab for movie nights, celebrations, warm-weather barbecues, or as a last-minute dessert for guests. The brand leans into playful, socially conscious positioning — Vermont roots, Fairtrade sourcing claims, and “cage-free eggs” language give it an ethical, slightly countercultural cachet aimed at millennials and families who want indulgence with a conscience. The label styling feels fun and friendly rather than clinical, with health-halo cues like “Vermont’s finest” and Fairtrade icons, though it is not organic. Packaging is a familiar paperboard pint (FSC: Mix noted on the box) that invites the spoon-right-in ritual. Sensory-wise you expect a rich, creamy mouthfeel, thick swirls of mix-ins and contrasting textures — the pint is presented as a shareable, indulgent treat: softening at room temperature, scooped with a spoon, and paired with celebrations or quiet comfort evenings. The ingredient list, however, includes a long roster of technical emulsifiers, stabilizers, and additives (e.g., cellulose gum, maltodextrin, silicas, flavored components), which reflects a high level of industrial processing. In plain terms, this is a convenience-focused, highly formulated frozen dessert designed for consistent texture, long shelf life and bold flavor rather than a minimal-ingredient homemade style ice cream. Its ritual is casual and celebratory: pull from the freezer, let soften, scoop and share.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Cyclopentasiloxane,Stearyl, Alcohol,, C12-15, Alkyl, Benzoate,, PPG-14, Butyl, Ether,, Hydrogenated, Castor, Oil,, Fragrance,, Polyethylne,, Caprylic/Capric, Triglyceride,, Sodium, Starch, Octenylsuccinate,, Maltodextrin,, Hydrated, Silica,, Hydrolyzed, Corn, Starch,, Gelatin, Crosspolymer,, BHT,, Silica,, Cellulose, Gum..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •BHT - Synthetic preservative
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
The product contains numerous industrial additives, emulsifiers, stabilizers, flavoring agents and highly processed components typical of ultra-processed foods, and is manufactured for consistency and long shelf life.
Explore Similar Products
Frozen Foods at Foodtown
See every Frozen Foods option at Foodtown
Ben & Jerry's products
Explore the full Ben & Jerry's lineup
Low Sodium Snacks
Heart-healthy low-sodium choices
Gluten-Free Staples
Safe choices for celiac and gluten sensitivity
Dairy-Free Snacks
No milk, cheese, or dairy ingredients
Dye-Free Snacks
No artificial colors or dyes
Others also viewed

Amy's Organic Pizza, Margherita
Amy's Kitchen

Lean Cuisine Favorites Macaroni & Beef
Lean Cuisine

Scott & Jons Shrimp Alfredo Pasta Bowl
Scott & Jon's

Hungry Man Sailsbury Steak
Hungry-Man
Chloe's Spider Man Strawberry Lemon Pops
Chloe's

Haagen-Dazs Sweet Lemon Coconut Sorbet
Haagen-Dazs

Talenti Gelato, Sea Salt Caramel
Talenti

Hungry Man Selects, Spicy Classic Fried Chicken
Hungry-Man

Chloe's Soft Serve Pops, Blueberry
Chloe's

Beyond Patties, Plant Based, Original 6 ea
Beyond

Totino's Cheese Pizza Rolls
Totino's

Hot Pockets Croissant Crust Bacon Egg Cheese
Hot Pockets
Common Questions about Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream, Everything But The
Defining 'healthy' can be a bit of a slippery slope! While Everything But The is undeniably delicious and packed with flavor, it does have a higher sugar and fat content than some other snacks. If you’re looking for a treat to enjoy in moderation, it fits the bill, but it may not be your go-to for everyday snacking.
