
Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream, Cherry Garcia
What You Should Know
Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia 16 fl oz sits in the frozen desserts section of grocery stores — usually in the premium pint aisle near other super-premium ice creams, novelty pints, and competitor premium brands. You’ll also see it on impulse freezer endcaps during warm months or near frozen novelties for parties. It’s a go-to pint for casual dessert occasions like movie night, backyard BBQs, weekend treat runs, or to cap off a dinner party. The brand leans into playful, countercultural roots and musician lore — marketed as a premium, indulgent comfort product that appeals to nostalgic Gen Xers, socially conscious millennials, and anyone seeking a rich, scoopable dessert. Labels emphasize health-adjacent and ethical claims — “non-GMO sourced ingredients,” “cage-free eggs,” and Fairtrade certification for cocoa and sugar — creating a natural/ethical halo even though the ingredient list includes added sugars, emulsifiers, and stabilizers. In plain terms, this is a churned, industrially produced ice cream: real dairy and fruit meet added sweeteners and functional ingredients to stabilize texture and shelf life. Sensory details: a dense, creamy mouthfeel with cold, velvety base, bursts of tart-sweet cherries and crunchy fudge flakes, and the faint chocolate-cocoa background; the ritual is scoop-to-bowl from a colorful cardboard pint with a plastic lid, often eaten straight from the container or spooned onto cake or warm pie. Overall it reads as a responsibly marketed, indulgent frozen treat that occupies the premium segment of American grocery freezers.
Nutrition Facts
Ingredients
Cream,, Skim, Milk,, Liquid, Sugar, (Sugar,, Water),, Water,, Cherries,, Sugar,, Egg, Yolks,, Coconut, Oil,, Cocoa, (Processed, with, Alkali),, Fruit, and, Vegetable, Concentrates, (Color),, Cocoa, Powder,, Guar, Gum,, Natural, Flavors,, Lemon, Juice, Concentrate,, Carrageenan,, Milk, Fat,, Soy, Lecithin..
Flagged Ingredients:
- •Coconut Oil - Seed oil high in omega-6 fatty acids
- •Soy Lecithin - Processed emulsifier
Dietary Labels
Ultra-Processing Assessment
Ultra-Processed
Why this score?
This product is classified as NOVA 4 because it is a ready-to-eat industrial formulation combining dairy and fruit with added sugars, emulsifiers/stabilizers (guar gum, carrageenan, soy lecithin), processed cocoa and 'natural flavors.' These processed ingredients and the manufactured nature of the pint align with the ultra-processed category.
Explore Similar Products
Others also viewed

Weight Watchers Smart Ones Fettuccini Alfredo Classic Favorites
Smart Ones
Red's All Natural Organic Chicken, Cilantro & Lime Burrito
Red's

Snickers Ice Cream Bar 2.8 fl oz
Snickers
White Castle Microwavable Cheeseburgers
White Castle

Friendly's Ice Cream, Rich & Creamy Coffee
Friendly's

McCain French Fries, Classic Cut
McCain

Nathans Onion Rings, Battered, Thick Sliced
Nathan's Famous

Mrs Ts Pierogies, Potato And Cheddar
Mrs. T's

Haagen-Dazs Ice Cream, Coffee
Haagen-Dazs

Haagen-Dazs Sorbet, Raspberry
Haagen-Dazs

Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream, Salted Caramel Core
Ben & Jerry's

Weight Watchers Smart Ones General TSO Chicken
Smart Ones
Common Questions about Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream, Cherry Garcia
Well, that depends on your definition of healthy! Cherry Garcia is a delicious treat with 340 calories per serving, so it's more of an indulgence than a health food. If you’re looking for a sweet escape after a long day, this ice cream can definitely hit the spot — just keep in mind it’s not your go-to for a daily snack.
